Bestsellers

Mayflower's most popular items, as decided by our loyal customers.

  • Mayflower Dawn Toro cigar beside an open box of 15 Mayflower Dawn Toro fresh pack of 5 cigars

    Mayflower Dawn Toro (6 x 54)

    The Mayflower Dawn. Finished with only the finest Ecuador Connecticut wrapper. Made with Nicaraguan long fillers and Cameroon binder. Subtle notes of wood, coffee, and cream. Well balanced...
    MSRP: $65.00 - $195.00
    $63.05 - $184.99
  • Mayflower Dawn Robusto cigar beside an open box of 15, rated 90 by CigarsLover Magazine Mayflower Dawn Robusto cigar beside an open box of 15

    Mayflower Dawn Robusto (5 x 50)

    The Mayflower Dawn. Finished with only the finest Ecuador Connecticut wrapper. Made with Nicaraguan long fillers and Cameroon binder. Subtle notes of wood, coffee, and cream. Well balanced...
    MSRP: $60.00 - $180.00
    $58.20 - $169.99
  • Mayflower Dawn Robusto, Toro and Churchill cigars in the 3-cigar sampler Mayflower Dawn 3-cigar sampler in a fresh pack
    Add to Cart The item has been added

    Mayflower Dawn 3-Cigar Assortment

    The Mayflower Dawn. Finished with only the finest Ecuador Connecticut wrapper. Made with Nicaraguan long fillers and Cameroon binder. Subtle notes of wood, coffee, and cream. Well balanced...
    MSRP: $40.00
    $39.20
    Add to Cart The item has been added
  • Mayflower Dusk Toro cigar beside an open box of 15, rated 91 by Cigar & Spirits Magazine Mayflower Dusk cigars stacked in a pyramid on a wooden plank

    Mayflower Dusk Toro (6.5 x 52)

    The Mayflower Dusk. Finished with only the finest Ecuador Habano wrapper. Made with Nicaraguan long fillers and Sumatra binder. Notes of cocoa, espresso, oak, and black pepper. Medium- to full-bodied.
    MSRP: $70.00 - $210.00
    $67.90 - $199.99
  • Mayflower Dusk Robusto cigar beside an open box of 15 Two Mayflower Dusk cigars on roasted coffee beans beside a cup of black coffee

    Mayflower Dusk Robusto (5.5 x 50)

    The Mayflower Dusk. Finished with only the finest Ecuador Habano wrapper. Made with Nicaraguan long fillers and Sumatra binder. Notes of cocoa, espresso, oak, and black pepper. Medium- to full-bodied.
    MSRP: $65.00 - $195.00
    $63.05 - $184.99
  • Mayflower Dusk Robusto, Toro and Toro Gordo cigars in the 3-cigar sampler Mayflower Dusk 3-cigar sampler in a fresh pack
    Add to Cart The item has been added

    Mayflower Dusk 3-Cigar Assortment

    The Mayflower Dusk. Finished with only the finest Ecuador Habano wrapper. Made with Nicaraguan long fillers and Sumatra binder. Notes of cocoa, espresso, oak, and black pepper. Medium- to full-bodied...
    MSRP: $43.00
    $42.14
    Add to Cart The item has been added
  • Open box of the Mayflower Trinity 8-Cigar Assortment with Mayflower Dawn, Mayflower Dusk and Mayflower Dream cigars
    Add to Cart The item has been added

    Mayflower Trinity 8-Cigar Assortment

    Sample all three of Mayflower's blends in a range of sizes, or give the perfect gift to a man that has it all. Mayflower Dawn – Finished with only the finest Ecuador Connecticut wrapper. Made with...
    $124.99
    Add to Cart The item has been added
  • One Toro each of Mayflower Dawn, Mayflower Dusk and Mayflower Dream in a fresh pack
    Add to Cart The item has been added

    Mayflower 3-Cigar Toro Assortment

    One each of our exquisite blends Mayflower Dawn, Mayflower Dusk, and Mayflower Dream in the ever-popular toro size. Mayflower Dawn (6 x 54) – Finished with only the finest Ecuador Connecticut wrapper...
    $42.99
    Add to Cart The item has been added
  • Mayflower Dream 3-cigar sampler with Robusto, Toro and Toro Gordo in a fresh pack
    Add to Cart The item has been added

    Mayflower Dream 3-Cigar Assortment

    The Mayflower Dream. This double-maduro blend features an exquisite Pennsylvania Broadleaf wrapper over Mexican San Andrés binder and Nicaraguan long filler. Expect soft, lingering notes of chicory,...
    $43.99
    Add to Cart The item has been added
  • Three fresh packs of 5 Robustos: Mayflower Dawn, Mayflower Dusk and Mayflower Dream
    Add to Cart The item has been added

    Mayflower Trinity Robusto Fresh Pack Bundle

    Sample all three of Mayflower's expertly crafted blends in the Robusto format. Preserved by Boveda® . Includes: 5 x Mayflower Dawn Robusto (5 x 50)Finished with only the finest Ecuador Connecticut...
    $198.75
    $168.94
    Add to Cart The item has been added
  • Mayflower 6-Cigar Assortment gift box shown closed and open, with six cigars inside Open Mayflower 6-Cigar Assortment box with a Robusto and a Toro of Mayflower Dawn, Mayflower Dusk and Mayflower Dream
    Add to Cart The item has been added

    Mayflower 6-Cigar Assortment

    Six cigars, two from each Mayflower blend, rest side by side in a box that closes with a quiet magnetic click. Inside are a Robusto and a Toro of Mayflower Dawn, Mayflower Dusk and Mayflower Dream,...
    $79.99
    Add to Cart The item has been added